Use access key #2 to skip to page content.

Market Mode Switches



March 31, 2009 – Comments (2)

They say that "nobody rings a bell" at market top or market bottom. And this seems to be true, if anything, market tops and bottoms are marked by articles about how it will continue to get more like this forever. Thus I am greatly cheered to hear that George Soros thinks the recession will go on forever.

Right now I am pondering market modes more than market tops and bottoms. It seems that the stock market has two general modes. One we usually refer to as a bull market. In it prices generally advance, although action in any day can do anything and there may be some pretty large corrections. The other is usually referred to as a bear market. I think this is a bit of misnomer as the market is more likely to thrash about wildly without actually making a lot of progress in any direction.

Now, tied in with market mode is investing style. In a bull market buy and hold works just fine. Also being fully invested works just fine as cash just drags down the returns on a portfolio. In a thrashing market carrying cash has some great advantages as you can snap up some bargains. And just buying and  holding may not work as well, especially if the stock does not pay a dividend.

Market modes seem to last long enough that they hit a blindspot in human cognition. We tend to extrapolate recent results into the future forever. So near the end of a bull market the percieved wisdom is that buy and hold is the ultimate strategy. And then after a while in a thrashing market buy and hold is considered to be dead forever. I now keep reading postings about how buy and hold is dead, so we are into that part of the process.

When will the next mode flip happen? Beats the heck out of me. I would not be surprised if it took several more years to work the credit crisis all the way through the system and lay the foundation for the next big run up.

There's something I've felt about the '02/03 turn down, which is it felt like it never quite finished. I base this feeling mostly on office space occupancy in my local area. A lot of office space went empty during it that never refilled during the '04/07 upturn. So in some ways this downturn feels like the washout that should have happened back then and didn't due to meddling by the fed. Watching what the fed and friends are doing now does not give me a warm feeling. But that's a topic for a different essay.

2 Comments – Post Your Own

#1) On April 06, 2009 at 12:54 PM, freddyv3 (< 20) wrote:

"The other is usually referred to as a bear market. I think this is a bit of misnomer as the market is more likely to thrash about wildly without actually making a lot of progress in any direction."


This is a foolish comment that shows a clear inability to deal with reality. The high of the last "churning" was around 9600 on the Dow and the low of next bear move was 6500 on the Dow. Even the high (so far) of this bull move is 17% below that 9600 high of the last bull move.

The author has taken one period (Sept 1008 to Dec 2008) in which we "thrashed about" and interpolated it to every other bear move and yet one only has to look at the slow and steady decline from early January to early March to see that there was no thrashing about but a relentless move downward of some 30%. BTW a 30% down move followed by a 30% up move is an overall down move of about 9%.

Please people, don't use hope and misinformation as an investing strategy. There are reasons to get long but this article only provides misinformation.

Report this comment
#2) On April 12, 2009 at 8:32 PM, chk999 (99.96) wrote:

Gee freddy, I just read your comment, sorry for not seeing it until now.

How about you make some CAPS picks and show us your chops. Then we'll have some basis to evaluate your points.

Report this comment

Featured Broker Partners