Use access key #2 to skip to page content.

EScroogeJr (< 20)

Surely you're joking, Mr. Bernanke



May 18, 2008 – Comments (2)

It's only today that I became aware of this link by reading the comments after dwot's last post (thanks, camistocks!) Anyway, Ron Paul grills Bernanke, citing a 20% increase in MZM  (this is Nov 2007), and Bernanke replies:

"Well, Congressman, first, just a small technical point. On the growth in money, money growth has been pretty moderate over the last few years. The increase in MZM is probably related to the financial turmoil. People have been taking their savings out of, you know, risky assets, putting them into the bank, and that makes the money data show faster growth.

So I’m not sure that’s indicative of policy, necessarily."

Unfortunately,  Bernanke was making his speach before congressmen, where there were no retarded ten-year-old children among his audience to laugh him out of the room, so he got away with this bullsh.t. However, we are not congressmen, so we can ask the following question. A risky asset is not a mattress that you can take your savings out of. In order for you to generate some sales proceeds to put in the bank, you must find a buyer for your asset, and that buyer has to take the same amount of money out the bank, either in the form of cash, or as credit. Credit has been contracting, if you believe Bernanke's complaints about the "liquidity crunch". It follows that the buyers of those securities had to remove cash from the bank at least at the same rate as the rate at which sellers were deposing their cash proceeds. So these transactions, which actually indicate nothing more profound than changes of ownership, cannot explain the growth of MZM. The reality is that one 2008 dollar is worth 80 cents of 2007 money because of overproduction of dollars by Bernanke & Co.

2 Comments – Post Your Own

#1) On May 18, 2008 at 9:34 PM, dwot (29.67) wrote:

I think it is way more complicated...

Has left me thinking...

Some where in there money is crossing borders, there are currency changes, there is asset deflation...

There's a lot going on... 

Report this comment
#2) On May 19, 2008 at 12:12 AM, camistocks (24.33) wrote:

Actually I was trying to make the point that the Fed isn't printing a lot of money at all. Bernanke was making fun of Ron Paul. I also first thought that the M3 money supply increase was because of the Fed is "printing like crazy". But it's the banks who are "printing" the money by giving out credit. The Fed has recently sold treasuries and thus has taken some money out of the system. Credit is still increasing not contracting. dwot is right, it is much more complicated. I am still looking and learning myself how the Fed works. 


Report this comment

Featured Broker Partners