Use access key #2 to skip to page content.

This stock's leavin'...on a midnight train to zero



June 15, 2010 – Comments (5) | RELATED TICKERS: VXX


Pardon the strange reference in my title, but I heard Gladys Knight yesterday and I've had her great song Midnight Train to Georgia on my mind ever since.

I came across a truly idiotic ETN yesterday.  I've never really liked ETFs or ETNs, but this one blew my mind when I read how it works.  If I understand this thing correctly, and I'm pretty sure that I do, it's almost guaranteed to be a losing bet over time.  It probably won't ever hit zero like I alluded to in the title, but it very likely will be cut in half again, and again, and again over the next several years with a few reverse splits thrown in to mask the pain.

What ETF am I talking about?  VXX, the S&P 500 Short Term VIX futures.  For those of you who aren't familiar with the term, the VIX essentially measures the volatility of the market.  The wilder the swings in the S&P 500 are, the higher the VIX will go.  This idiotic thing lost 82% of its value in 2009, yet it still has a market cap of nearly a billion dollars.

Theoretically an ETF or an ETN that tracks the volatility of the market is an interesting idea.  The problem is that this the way this specific stock works is flawed.  VXX is not directly linked to the volatility index, instead it attempts to replicate its activity using a rolling futures portfolio.  The way futures contracts usually work, longer term contracts are more expensive than short term ones.  In this specific case, Mr. Market usually assumes that volatility will be higher down the road than it is today.  The phenomenon of future contracts being more expensive than near term ones is called contango.

The fact that the VIX futures market is normally in contango means that every single month when the folks who run this ETN lose money when they sell the cheaper near term futures and roll the funds cash over into a longer term contract.  Unless the market the market goes into backwardation (essentially the opposite of contango), and such an occurrence is much less common than contango, this fund will inherently lose money month, after month, after month.  The chart at the top of this post illustrates how the VXX under-performs the VIX over time. 

Of course there are exceptions to this rule.  As I mentioned the futures market does go into backwardation from time to time and of course something wild like Iran going postal or crazy riots in Greece, etc... could cause a major spike in market volatility.  Still over time, especially in CAPS where one can endure the pain of a temporary spike in volatility for free, I strongly believe that the inherent friction way it works will cause VXX to be a big loser.  That of course means free points in the game that we all love.

The funny thing is that I came across this idiotic ETN late yesterday and I thought to myself who in the heck would ever buy this trash other than for a very, very short term trade?  On the drive home from work, I was listening to Bloomberg radio and I actually heard one of the "advisors" that Pim Fox was interviewing recommend this dumb thing.  Good grief. 



5 Comments – Post Your Own

#1) On June 15, 2010 at 11:12 AM, eatenbybears (< 20) wrote:

Interesting proposal, but I do not understand wher you get your VXX last price at $18.745.  I show it at $27.44

 Those of us who have been trading VXX since the spring may feel its moves have been very profitable and a easy vehicle to be able to move in and out of volatility bets.

 Unless I am not understanding what you are discussing, My VXX chart and your VXX chart dont match;range=6m;compare=vix;indicator=volume;charttype=line;crosshair=on;ohlcvalues=0;logscale=on;source=undefined

Report this comment
#2) On June 15, 2010 at 11:32 AM, TMFDeej (97.93) wrote:

Thanks bears.  That's an older chart that I clipped from an article, just to show the divergence between the VXX and the VIX.  

The one that you provided a link to is more up to date.


Report this comment
#3) On June 15, 2010 at 11:46 AM, eatenbybears (< 20) wrote:

It is only useful as a trading vehicle, and only in unsure time ... so yes, it is a stupid fund.  But with Spain, Greece, the EU, US interest rate questions, 9%+ unemployment, still slow manufacturing, oil well leaks, the arrival of Hurricane season. Misc. Volcanoes and earthquakes, revolts in Kurdistan or whatever Stan that is they are asking the Russians to come into,Iran, commodities ....... It does have its use short term.

 Since the world is scheduled to end Dec 21, 2012 .. it is in reality a short term fund as all known  volatility will end ... or will it go off the chart ... will there be a chart?


Report this comment
#4) On June 15, 2010 at 11:59 AM, TMFDeej (97.93) wrote:

HAHA.  I saw a hilarious cartoon on this subject in Barron's this weekend, which is surprising because usually the cartoons in it are beyond terrible.

It showed a couple cruising down the road in a convertible and the husband was telling the wife "Don't worry honey, I'm sure that I can hold the creditors off until the world ends in 2012."


Report this comment
#5) On June 17, 2010 at 1:24 PM, cdulan (< 20) wrote:

Deej, I think you are throwing the baby out with the bath water on this one.  Yes, the decay is horrible. Yes, divergence is ugly. 

But when volatility reverts to the mean and you have major economic shocks lurking the VXX is the purest play available short of VIX options.   You cannot deny that going long VXX at $18 was easy money.  So I am sure there scenarios you would be long VXX.  That level was way to low for type of issues we are dealing with.   My point is that however flawed, it has a use.

Report this comment

Featured Broker Partners