Hello, Fool! | Login | Signup | My Fool
Jul 9, 2008 4:20 AM ET | Site Changes | Help
Search: Tickers Company Names Players
The Company is an owner, operator and franchisor of restaurants featuring a variety of boldly-flavored, made-to-order menu items including Buffalo, chicken wings etc.
View All Commentary (BWLD)
Recs
TMFDeej (99.44) Submitted: 4/30/08 1:44 PM : Start Price: $31.35 BWLD Score: 0.21
actually am probably a little early on this call, so you don’t have to run out and sell your restaurant stocks immediately, but you probably should do so fairly soon. Restaurant earnings might be pretty decent for the next quarter or two, but this sector is headed for a lot of pain in the relatively near future. Why you ask? Because a huge spike in meat prices is coming and consumer spending is going to slow. As everyone already knows, the prices of commodities, like corn and soybeans have exploded. There is always a significant lag between an increase in feed cost and the subsequent increase in meat prices. At least that is what happened the last time feed prices doubled in the 1970s. When feed costs increase significantly as a result of a rally in corn and soybean prices, the first reaction of individual livestock feeders is to try to tough it out with the hope their competitors down the road will reduce production first. It's sort of a game of chicken, so to speak. When the industry at large fails to reduce production, individual livestock feeders begin to lose massive amounts of money and they are forced to begin to cut production. This "cut back" means the livestock producers will cull their sow (that's a female pig) herd and/or their cow herd. In the short term, this will put more meat on the market, causing meat prices trade lower. This is exactly what we have been seeing lately with meat prices.According to people in the industry who I have spoken with, there is currently a three-week wait to have sows slaughtered because the demand is so high and meat packers only have so much capacity. The lag period before we see higher pork prices is likely to be around 9 to 12 months. For beef it is a little longer, probably at least 12 months. Once the increase in meat prices begins, it will likely last for several years. This is how it has happened in the past. Smart meat futures traders have been “Bear Spreading” hog and cattle futures i.e. selling the nearby contracts and buying the deferred contracts for the reasons stated above.I became intrigued by this whole phenomenon when a former holding of mine, Buffalo Wild Wings (BWLD) reported not that long ago that chicken wing prices were falling. When I heard that I said to myself, “how can this be…grain prices are through the roof?” I did some of research on the subject and I now understand the dynamics of the meat industry and why this happened. I can only hope for shareholders’ sakes that BWLD has recently or is able to sign a long-term contract for wings in the near future, as they have done in the past. Doing so would be a brilliant move. BWLD management has proven to be very capable in the past, so perhaps they will. I love this chain. The food, the atmosphere, and of course the beer are all great. I go there whenever I can, but I finally decided to sell my Buffalo Wild Wings shares and those of any other restaurants that I owned. I just don’t want to fight this powerful trend. This is a well-run company we’re talking about here, some of the less well run ones in the United States are going to be blindsided by this rise in prices and get absolutely crushed.As you can see, on one hand it is very likely that U.S. restaurant margins are going to be squeezed by higher input costs. As if this wasn’t bad enough, I suspect that the massive increases in food and gas prices are going to force consumers to cut back on discretionary spending for fun things, such as going out to eat. Not to mention the fact that consumer confidence is currently sitting at its lowest level in fifteen years. Falling revenues caused by a drop in consumer spending combined with rising expenses spell disaster for restaurants. --------------------------------------------------------------------------I have talked about the rapidly approaching spike in meat prices and a likely slowown in consumer spending cause by higher food and gas prices already. The article brought something to my attention that I hadn't thought of yet, the impending rise in the minimum wage. Regardless of what you think about whether we should have a minimum wage or what it should be, there's no denying that raising it is going to cause pain for some industries. States are free to set their own minimum wage, but the federal government sets a floor that they cannot go below. For those of you who aren't familiar with the Fair Minimum Wage Act of 2007, officially signed on May 25, 2007 the law will raise the federal minimum wage from its current level of $5.85 to $6.55 on July 24, 2007 and to $7.25 on July 24, 2009. Twenty-seven of the fifty states currently have lower minimum wages than the new 2008 federal rate and 41 of the 50 are lower than new 2009 federal level. According to some quick searches that I did on the web, supposedly two-thirds of all minimum wage workers are employed in the food services industry. This is not good news for restaurants. They are going to get bombarded from every possible angle by, increasing food input costs, slowing consumer demand, and rising wages for their employees. Ouch. DeejNo position in BWLD
Report this Post Replies: 9 | Reply
Oops! There appears to be a problem with your comment. Check to see if there's something you left out.
bullshiite (97.91) Submitted: 4/30/08 7:18 PM
Recs: 0 | Rec This
Great post. Never would have thought higher feed prices lead to a short-term drop in meat prices, followed by an increase, but your post explains the logic behind that pattern.
Report this Post Reply
TMFDeej (99.44) Submitted: 5/01/08 9:27 AM
Thanks.Deej
synergize (95.65) Submitted: 5/01/08 12:44 PM
Recent earnings report says it was up. The stock price actually went down last year. So I don't know what's going on. I also have an underperform pitch on this betting against the good news. My thought is that with high gas prices, low consumer spending and increasing jobless claims, it will bring down the stock lower.Will you eat and dine in the restaurant with your unemployment money?
lepant (86.19) Submitted: 5/01/08 1:24 PM
Excellent post, brought up some interesting points I never would of thought of plus with the recent now may be indeed the time to be short.
tharptx (92.24) Submitted: 5/08/08 10:45 AM
Best post I've ever read on CAPS - bravo!
LookMomBoogers (95.91) Submitted: 5/08/08 3:11 PM
Recs: 2 | Rec This
Two parts of your post are very sound, I have a small problem with part of your thought proccess, though. Here is my observation:I majored in Animal Science (which is the Ag based animal science) before I switched my degree program, your post emphasizes that producers are culling their production herds and then it infers that these production type females are causing the price of meat to drop as there is too much supply on the market. However, you haven't taken into account how the USDA grades meat, most of the meat that is used for public consumption is under 2 years of age in beef, and under 1 in pork. Meat that is older (your production sows) rarely is graded for anything more valuable then dog food. This is even more true in the poultry industry where none of the poultry you eat has been fed for longer then a couple of months (guess I don't know about ducks and turkeys). I agree some of the cost of high corn will be passed on to the consumer, however the rate at which the US imports meat (poultry and beef specifically) should help keep prices from being the factor that sinks the restaurant industry.Thanks for your time.
monksnake (21.42) Submitted: 5/13/08 3:02 AM
This post actually was a huge push in me selling out of my shares in BWLD. It makes total sense and I expect what Deej says to happen. After the earnings runup, I sold out my position and will wait for a new entry point after a nice drop. Great post Deej.
Errc02 (86.90) Submitted: 5/29/08 4:33 PM
Recs: 1 | Rec This
Excellent post! I think your prediction will come true for a vast majority of the restaurant industry, but I still believe BWLD will outperform. You mentioned management's aptitude for cost control, and I've personally never been in a Buffalo Wild Wings that wasn't packed wall to wall. That says to me that they should have the ability to pass on their costs to their customers without much slowdown. I also don't think the squeeze on discretionary income will affect BWLD too much either. Consumers are more likely to sacrifice higher priced meals at Cheesecake Factory and PF Chang's before they give up relatively low cost beer and wings. I definitely agree that BWLD stock could suffer near term with the rest of the industry, but still a long term outperform.
DNAdivaSTL (60.33) Submitted: 6/03/08 11:09 AM
I have to disagree with your call on this one. A recent human intrest story on the St. Louis Fox affiliate stated that the local restaurants that will suffer through this recession are the middle to high dollar places...people will cut back on fancier meals but will maintain relationships with local neighborhood-based places, i.e., BWLD.