Selective Insurance Group (NASDAQ:SIGI)

CAPS Rating: 4 out of 5

The Company through its subsidiaries, offers property and casualty insurance products and diversified insurance products.

SIGI News and Commentary

Caps

How do you think SIGI will perform against the market?

Add Stock to CAPS Watchlist

All Players

50 Outperform
6 Underperform
 

All-Star Players

18 Outperform
1 Underperform
 

Wall Street

3 Outperform
0 Underperform
 

Top SIGI Bull/Bear Pitches

The best Bull and Bear pitches based on recency and number of recommendations.

goochb1 (63.13)
Submitted March 25, 2008

Selective Insurance engaged in major cost cutting initiatives at the beginning of 2008 in order to "shore up" its one major vulnerability in the industry. Selective has been a historically strong performer however, in recent years the direct… More

mtthwpigott (24.49)
Submitted February 13, 2007

even when this stock splits on Feb 20, the P/E ratio below 10 only tells me that they are working things out. If you are in currently, sell right after the split and you will come out with a 50 cent extra dividend

SIGI VS S&P 500 (SPY)

Fools bullish on SIGI are also bullish on:

Recent Community Commentary

Read the most recent pitches from players about SIGI.

Recs

0
Member Avatar dreamjob (79.42) Submitted: 11/28/2015 9:34:03 AM : Outperform Start Price: $33.56 SIGI Score: +52.57

Profitable and cheap, growing sales and earnings while paying a dividend. Earnings quality is very good and ROIC is impressive.

Recs

0
Member Avatar elyk13 (26.33) Submitted: 12/19/2014 11:43:18 AM : Underperform Start Price: $25.31 SIGI Score: -107.62

Their E&S division will continue to erode profitability. Mesa Underwriters lacks underwriting discipline - currently underwriting multiple classes under ISO loss cost estimates. Increasing exposure to oil and gas classes of business in the western US at below market rates will lead to further negativity in the E&S division's combined ratio. Shock and construction defect losses in NV, CO, and AZ will eventually present themselves and at that time the underwriting drag on this company from the E&S division will move from the 9% mark currently to much worse levels. The increased market share from the low underwriting rates will not be enough to overcome the inevitable losses.

Recs

0
Member Avatar 5SsmallcapDIV (78.54) Submitted: 1/18/2011 10:41:20 AM : Outperform Start Price: $15.47 SIGI Score: +180.77

5 STAR, Small-cap, dividend payer

Leaderboard

Find the members with the highest scoring picks in SIGI.

Score Leader

gembree

gembree (99.87) Score: +264.67

The Score Leader is the player with the highest score across all their picks in SIGI.

Top
Pick
Member Name Member
Rating
Start
Date
Call Time
Frame
Start
Price
Stock
Gain
Index
Gain
Score Commentary
gembree 99.87 2/25/2009 Outperform 5Y $9.64 +510.89% +246.22% +264.67 0 Comment
SavantTheIdiot 95.24 2/23/2009 Outperform NS $10.32 +470.68% +235.29% +235.39 0 Comment
spiril 26.10 2/2/2010 Outperform NS $12.76 +361.71% +134.65% +227.05 0 Comment
metaBot < 20 6/27/2011 Outperform 5Y $13.73 +328.86% +103.22% +225.65 0 Comment
Jedson81 94.76 11/19/2009 Outperform 5Y $12.81 +359.94% +135.30% +224.65 0 Comment
frys867 39.66 6/17/2010 Outperform 5Y $13.16 +347.46% +131.66% +215.80 0 Comment
Kilroy9376 95.70 2/11/2010 Outperform 5Y $12.95 +354.86% +141.28% +213.58 0 Comment
SmallCapsInvstr 85.75 5/11/2009 Outperform 5Y $11.84 +397.39% +184.13% +213.27 0 Comment
stockleecher 22.98 3/12/2010 Outperform NS $13.85 +325.18% +122.95% +202.24 0 Comment
daveshunny < 20 4/29/2011 Outperform 5Y $15.25 +286.28% +89.38% +196.90 0 Comment

Wall Street

See what the Wall Street professionals think, according to their public statements and filings.

Player Name Player
Rating
Start
Date
Call Time
Frame
Start
Price
Stock
Gain
S&P
Gain
Score End Date Commentary
TrackBofASec 93.77 4/25/2014 Outperform NS $21.63 +172.28% +37.74% +134.54 0 Comment
TrackBofASec 93.77 10/10/2007 Outperform NS $22.64 +11.47% -14.27% +25.73 3/24/2008 @ $25.24 0 Comment
TrackDreman 65.75 9/30/2007 Outperform NS $16.57 +255.44% +77.07% +178.38 2 Comments
TrackChrisDavis 93.45 9/30/2007 Outperform NS $16.57 +255.44% +77.07% +178.38 1 Comment

Featured Broker Partners