$10.45 $0.09 (0.9%)

04:00 PM EDT on 09/20/19

PICO Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ:PICO)

CAPS Rating: No stars

A diversified holding company seeks to build and operate businesses where value can be created from the development of unique assets, and to acquire businesses. The Company's objective is to maximize long-term shareholder value.

Current Price $10.45 Mkt Cap $192.9M
Open $10.39 P/E Ratio 0.00
Prev. Close $10.36 Div. (Yield) $0.00 (0.0%)
Daily Range $10.31 - $10.65 Volume 97,689
52-Wk Range $8.97 - $11.82 Avg. Daily Vol. 1


How do you think NASDAQ:PICO will perform against the market?

Add Stock to CAPS Watchlist

All Players

250 Outperform
15 Underperform

All-Star Players

42 Outperform
4 Underperform

Wall Street

2 Outperform
0 Underperform

Top NASDAQ:PICO Bull/Bear Pitches

The best Bull and Bear pitches based on recency and number of recommendations.

demeye (98.78)
Submitted December 31, 2007

this is a water stock. "this company owns an astounding 134,130 acre-feet of water rights."The company actually began life in the insurance business, and used the free float from their insurance operations to buy up water rights (along with some… More

Top Bear Pitch

There are no pitches that meet the Top Bear criteria. Explain

If this upsets you, start recommending pitches below!


Fools bullish on NASDAQ:PICO are also bullish on:

Fools bearish on NASDAQ:PICO are also bearish on:

Recent Community Commentary

Read the most recent pitches from players about PICO.


Member Avatar TMFDeej (97.89) Submitted: 10/20/2016 10:30:22 AM : Outperform Start Price: $9.23 NASDAQ:PICO Score: -26.64

Barron's wrote a bullish article on PICO holdings last month. At the time I penned (do you still call it penned when there's actually no pen or paper involved) a skeptical rebuttal to the piece here:

Is a Turnaround Really in the Works at PICO Holdings?


From the post...

Sounds great, but a few things bother me about PICO. One, the whole "water" investment thesis has been pretty trendy for a while, but so far it hasn't panned out. For years people have been talking about how water is such a precious resource and that companies in the sector will do tremendously well. They've even built water ETFs. Thus far the outperformance of water stocks has not materialized. Here's a chart that compares the performance of four popular water stock tracking ETFs to the S&P 500.


The underperformance is obvious. So the water is the future investment thesis thus far has been a complete bust.

Another thing that bothers me about PICO is its management. I don't trust that its management can effectively manage shareholder funds. From the Barron's article:

PICO made a poor acquisition of a canola-processing business in Minnesota that it sold last year.

Yuck, what a waste. Adding insult to injury, PICO's management is grossly overpaid relative to the performance of the company's stock. I have no problem paying up for effective management, but when a company's stock has been terrible for years management should not be rewarded (see NSAM, grrrrrr).

Terrible management was a big part of the reason why I didn't like PICO. Well, it seems as though that has changed. The activist investors who were involved with the company won and on October 12th, PICO's board of directors announced that it had fired the company's CEO John R. Hart. In a new article, Barron's believes that this is good news for shareholders and I'm inclined to agree.

This Water Rights Firm’s Stock Can Spring Higher

PICO Holdings’ long-serving CEO has left the company, which is now poised to unlock shareholder value.


No position in PICO


Member Avatar MrMonopoly (< 20) Submitted: 3/15/2014 9:09:13 AM : Outperform Start Price: $18.71 NASDAQ:PICO Score: -104.90

"Developing unique assets". Does that sound more dignified than "developing resource monopolies"? Brilliant plan, to sell 1 million acres but not the water rights people need to survive there.


Member Avatar bike5389 (< 20) Submitted: 1/22/2014 1:05:34 PM : Outperform Start Price: $17.53 NASDAQ:PICO Score: -102.20

no snow in the west water rights will increase in value


Find the members with the highest scoring picks in PICO.

Score Leader


TMEBenBenBen (< 20) Score: +335.49

The Score Leader is the player with the highest score across all their picks in PICO.

Member Name Member
Call Time
Score Commentary
TMEBenBenBen < 20 3/16/2009 Underperform NS $17.70 -40.97% +294.52% +335.49 0 Comment
Tuusa 98.59 1/16/2009 Underperform 3M $18.59 -43.78% +262.28% +306.05 1 Comment
upbatter 66.51 10/15/2008 Underperform 5Y $20.96 -50.14% +225.70% +275.84 0 Comment
1203cc < 20 7/14/2008 Underperform 1Y $31.85 -67.19% +145.51% +212.70 1 Comment
ManicTrader 22.58 3/23/2007 Underperform 3W $32.56 -67.91% +120.13% +188.04 0 Comment
brogers146 70.86 11/25/2011 6/24/2014 Underperform 5Y $14.53 -28.06% +156.35% +184.41 0 Comment
MrClower 70.52 4/8/2008 Underperform 3M $24.68 -57.66% +126.58% +184.24 2 Comments
parmens 76.39 5/13/2008 Underperform 1Y $26.48 -60.54% +120.57% +181.11 0 Comment
skiprof < 20 4/7/2008 Underperform 1Y $23.06 -54.68% +124.34% +179.02 0 Comment
tallenuk 23.30 5/23/2012 Underperform 1Y $15.40 -32.15% +127.31% +159.46 0 Comment

Wall Street

See what the Wall Street professionals think, according to their public statements and filings.

Player Name Player
Call Time
Score End Date Commentary
tracknorthlandca < 20 6/21/2013 Outperform NS $14.98 -30.25% +86.88% -117.13 0 Comment
trackmerriman 67.85 9/29/2006 Outperform NS $22.70 -53.97% +136.72% -190.69 0 Comment